Upper Tribunal Appeals Solicitor

If your benefits appeal has been unsuccessful, I can review the First-tier Tribunal’s written reasons and advise whether an error of law gives you grounds for a further appeal.

I’m Prakash Ruparelia, an Upper Tribunal appeals solicitor practising through Scott-Moncrieff and Associates Limited. My work covers PIP, Universal Credit, ESA and benefit overpayment cases across England and Wales.

You can instruct me to assess the decision, prepare grounds for permission to appeal or advise after the First-tier Tribunal has refused permission.

Handshake between a solicitor and client

A published £38,000 overpayment result

The First-tier Tribunal initially dismissed a client’s appeal against a combined ESA and Housing Benefit overpayment of £38,000.

The Upper Tribunal set aside that decision and returned the case for a fresh hearing. At the rehearing, the First-tier Tribunal allowed the appeal in full and found that the overpayment was not recoverable.

I assess each further appeal on its own evidence and legal grounds.

Read the published case summary.

Reviewing a tribunal decision for an error of law

An Upper Tribunal appeal requires an arguable legal error that could have affected the outcome.

Possible errors include:

  • Applying the wrong legal test or interpreting the law incorrectly.
  • Giving inadequate reasons for an important finding.
  • Failing to address evidence relevant to the decision.
  • Reaching a finding without adequate evidential support.
  • Conducting the proceedings unfairly.

I review the tribunal’s reasoning alongside the relevant appeal papers and explain which points could support a challenge. You receive advice on how those points relate to the outcome and the practical value of pursuing them.

Obtaining the statement of reasons

The tribunal’s statement of reasons explains how it reached its decision and is usually central to assessing an appeal.

To obtain written reasons, send a written request to the First-tier Tribunal. It normally needs to arrive within one month of the date the tribunal sent or otherwise provided the decision notice. Keep copies of the notice and your request.

If that period has passed, include the relevant dates and an explanation of the delay when enquiring so I can consider whether an extension can be sought.

Permission to appeal and the tribunal’s own review

You first apply to the First-tier Tribunal for permission to appeal. Where there are suitable grounds, I prepare a written application identifying the legal errors and explaining why they matter.

On receiving a permission application, the First-tier Tribunal must first consider whether to review its decision. Where appropriate, the tribunal can set aside its decision on review. The First-tier Tribunal can then reconsider the case.

The permission application normally needs to reach the tribunal within one month of it sending the written reasons, although subsequent tribunal decisions can affect the deadline. I check the correspondence to establish the date that applies. Read the First-tier Tribunal Procedure Rules.

Applying directly to the Upper Tribunal

If the First-tier Tribunal refuses permission, you can apply directly to the Upper Tribunal. It normally needs to arrive within one calendar month of the First-tier Tribunal sending its decision on permission. Read the HMCTS information about form UT1.

If either tribunal grants permission, further work can include written submissions, responding to the DWP’s arguments and representation at a hearing where we agree this.

Where the Upper Tribunal sets aside a decision, it may make a replacement decision itself or return the case to the First-tier Tribunal for reconsideration. I explain the possible outcomes and any further preparation a new hearing would involve.

Fees and funding

My service is privately funded. We agree the scope and fee for each stage in writing. You can instruct me for an initial review before deciding whether to proceed with drafting or representation.

Legal aid may be available through an appropriate provider for some Upper Tribunal work, subject to the applicable eligibility requirements. Read the GOV.UK information about further benefits appeals and legal aid.

For an appeal awaiting its first hearing, further information is available about PIP appeals and welfare benefits tribunal representation.

Discuss your tribunal decision

A brief initial discussion is free. Detailed document review, advice and drafting are paid services.

Tell me which benefit is involved and when the tribunal sent its decision, written reasons and any refusal of permission.

Telephone 020 3972 9011
Email info@specialistsolicitor.co.uk

Fill out this field
Fill out this field
Please enter a valid email address.
Fill out this field
Fill out this field
You need to agree with the terms to proceed